As a Spanish teacher, this week is my least favorite time of year. All of a sudden all you see are sombreros and piñatas. Must mean another Cinco de Mayo is upon us. You would think as a Spanish teacher I would be excited about this "holiday", but instead I just become frustrated, embarrassed, and insulted.
Despite many people's assumption, Cinco de Mayo is not an national holiday in Mexico. It is certainly NOT Independence Day and in fact, is celebrated more in the United States, than in Mexico. It does not represent all people who speak Spanish, because Latinos are not all Mexican. But like I said, it does not even represent Mexico. In fact, most Mexicans are actually insulted by people who wish them a "Happy Cinco de Mayo".
To read the history of Cinco de Mayo, which represents ONE battle at the town of Puebla that the Mexicans won against the French (although they did end up losing the war, and France imposed a relative of Napoleon as the ruler of Mexico for a short period), check out
MexOnline's page.
Now, just imagine the people of Mexico wishing an American a Happy May 4th. Why May 4th? Well, that's the day the Confederate Army defeated the Union at the Battle of Chancellorsville. Imagine Mexican having huge parties every year with American flags, celebrating American Independence. You mean no one celebrates this day in the United States? It's not Independence Day? Well, neither is Cinco de Mayo celebrated in Mexico, besides the actual town of Puebla, where the battle originally took place.
So teachers, please stop celebrating this with your students. There is more to the Mexican culture than sombreros and piñatas. For a FREE lesson about 1
0 Misconceptions that exist in the US about Spanish and the people who speak it, download our 10 slide powerpoint. It's time we start educating our students with actual facts and not perpetuate Commercial/Beer Holidays.
For more information, read my blog post about
why I don't celebrate Cinco de Mayo and read this year's post on
what Mexicans think of Cinco de Mayo along with free resources.
So if you see someone who speaks Spanish this upcoming weekend, do us all a favor and do not wish them a Happy Cinco de Mayo. They'll be glad you didn't.
-Justin
SpanishPlans.org